Navigating government information can be complex, and sometimes the responses you receive through the Right to Information (RTI) Act, 2005, can leave you more confused than before. This case highlights a common pitfall: contradictory replies from public authorities. If you’ve ever faced conflicting information from a Public Information Officer (PIO) and the First Appellate Authority (FAA), this article will explain what happened and what you can learn.
Background: What Information Was Sought
In this instance, an RTI applicant wanted to know about the actions taken regarding a complaint filed women officers working in a specific government department. The applicant submitted an RTI application seeking details about the follow-up on this complaint. However, the response received was far from straightforward, leading to a second appeal before the Central Information Commission (CIC).
How the Public Authority Responded
The Public Information Officer (PIO) initially denied the requested information. The PIO cited Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act, which allows for the withholding of personal information that has no relation to public activity or interest, or that would cause an unwarranted invasion of privacy. This is a common ground for denial, but it implies that some information *does* exist. However, when the applicant pursued the matter to the First Appellate Authority (FAA), the FAA took a completely different stance. The FAA stated that no such complaint had even been made Group-A women officers. This created a direct contradiction: the PIO denied information based on its personal nature, while the FAA claimed the information didn’t exist because the complaint itself was non-existent.
The CIC Hearing: What Happened
The applicant, understandably frustrated opposing statements, escalated the matter to the Central Information Commission (CIC) through a second appeal. The core of the applicant’s argument was precisely this contradiction. They contended that the PIO and FAA had provided conflicting versions of the situation, making it impossible to ascertain the truth. The CIC carefully examined the arguments presented applicant and the responses from the public authority. The Commission acknowledged that the applicant’s point about the contradictory replies was valid.
The CIC Order and Its Significance
The CIC, in its decision, highlighted a crucial point. If the competent authority had indeed confirmed that no complaint was filed, the PIO should have simply responded with ‘nil’ information. Invoking Section 8(1)(j) suggests that there *is* information, but it’s personal. If there’s no complaint, there’s no information to be personal or public. Therefore, the PIO’s initial denial under Section 8(1)(j) was inappropriate if the FAA’s claim of no complaint was correct. Despite recognizing the contradiction, the Commission ultimately upheld the order of the First Appellate Authority and rejected the second appeal. This means that while the contradiction was noted, the Commission did not penalize the department or force them to provide information beyond what the FAA had stated (i.e., no complaint existed).
Key Lessons for RTI Applicants
- Lesson 1: Identify Contradictory Replies: Always scrutinize the PIO’s and FAA’s responses. If they seem to contradict each other, this is a strong ground for your second appeal to the CIC.
- Lesson 2: ‘Nil’ Information is Different from ‘Exempt’ Information: Understand that denying information under Section 8(1)(j) implies existence but exemption. If no record exists, the correct response is ‘nil’ information.
- Lesson 3: CIC May Uphold FAA Even with Contradictions: While the CIC may point out inconsistencies, they might still uphold the FAA’s decision if they believe the core information sought (or its non-existence) has been established at the appellate stage, even if the initial PIO response was flawed.
How to File a Similar RTI Application
- Draft Your RTI Application Clearly: State precisely what information you are seeking. Be specific about the complaint, the officers involved (if public interest dictates), and the actions taken.
- Submit to the Correct PIO: Ensure your application is sent to the Public Information Officer of the department that holds the information.
- Follow Up on the PIO’s Reply: If the reply is unsatisfactory, vague, or denied, file a First Appeal within 30 days to the FAA.
- File a Second Appeal with the CIC: If the FAA’s decision is also not satisfactory, you can file a Second Appeal with the Central Information Commission (or State Information Commission) within 90 days of the FAA’s order. Clearly state the contradictions in the PIO and FAA responses in your appeal.
Sample RTI question you can use:
Please provide details of the action taken department on the complaint filed by [mention designation or group, e.g., Group-A women officers] on [date, if known] regarding [briefly state the subject of the complaint]. If no complaint was filed, please provide confirmation of ‘nil’ information.
Conclusion
This case serves as a reminder that while the RTI Act is a powerful tool, public authorities may not always provide perfect responses. Being aware of potential inconsistencies and understanding how to navigate the appeals process is crucial. documenting your interactions and presenting clear arguments, you can effectively use the RTI Act to seek transparency and accountability from government bodies.

