Every Indian citizen has the right to know how public authorities function, and sometimes this includes understanding the process of addressing grievances against those in high positions. This case highlights how the Right to Information Act, 2005 (RTI Act) can be used to seek clarity even on sensitive matters, such as complaints against judges. If you’ve ever wondered about the transparency in handling such complaints, this article will explain what information you can potentially access and how the Central Information Commission (CIC) has ruled.
Background: What Information Was Sought
In this RTI case, an applicant wanted to know the status and details of complaints filed against serving and retired Judges of High Courts and the Supreme Court, including the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of India. Specifically, the applicant requested copies of these complaints and the forwarding letters sent Department of Justice to the Supreme Court and High Courts regarding these complaints. This information is crucial for understanding the accountability mechanisms within the judiciary.
How the Public Authority Responded
The Public Information Officer (PIO) initially responded that the requested letters were issued more than three years ago. The PIO claimed that compiling copies of these documents would be time-consuming and that the information was maintained in different files, suggesting it would disproportionately divert the resources of the public authority. This is a common tactic used public authorities to deny information, often citing Section 7(9) of the RTI Act, which allows for exemptions if the disclosure would ‘disproportionately divert the resources of the public authority’. The appellant, however, argued that at least the forwarding letters from the past year should be provided, and for older requests, whatever information was readily available should be shared.
The CIC Hearing: What Happened
The matter eventually reached the Central Information Commission (CIC) for adjudication. During the hearing, the applicant reiterated their request, emphasizing the public interest in transparency. The CIC examined the PIO’s response and the arguments presented. The Commission acknowledged the difficulty in retrieving very old records but also recognized the spirit of the RTI Act, which aims to provide access to information unless specifically exempted. The CIC noted that the public authority’s inability to easily retrieve information indicated a potential lapse in their record-keeping practices, which is a violation of the principles of good governance and the RTI Act’s objectives.
The CIC Order and Its Significance
The CIC delivered a significant order that balanced the applicant’s right to information with the practical challenges of record retrieval. The Commission directed the PIO to provide the copies of all forwarding letters pertaining to complaints against judges for the past one year. Furthermore, the CIC ordered the PIO to make a diligent effort to trace and provide copies of any forwarding letters that could be found for the past three years. Crucially, the CIC also admonished the public authority for its inadequate record-keeping. The Commission directed the public authority to improve its record maintenance system to ensure that information sought under the RTI Act can be retrieved easily and efficiently in the future. This directive aims to prevent future delays and denials based on poor record management.
Key Lessons for RTI Applicants
- Lesson 1: Be Specific but Flexible While it’s important to be clear about what information you need, be prepared to accept what is readily available if retrieving older records proves exceptionally difficult for the public authority. The appellant’s willingness to accept information for the past year and whatever could be traced for three years was a practical approach.
- Lesson 2: Challenge Vague Denials If a PIO cites ‘disproportionate diversion of resources’ without providing a clear explanation or making a genuine effort to retrieve information, challenge this denial. The CIC often scrutinizes such claims and may direct the authority to provide information if their record-keeping is found wanting.
- Lesson 3: Focus on Record Keeping The CIC’s directive for better record maintenance is a vital takeaway. It emphasizes that public authorities have a responsibility not just to respond to RTI requests but also to maintain their records in an organized manner, making transparency a proactive process.
How to File a Similar RTI Application
- Identify the Correct Public Authority: Determine which department or office is responsible for handling complaints against judges (e.g., Department of Justice, Supreme Court Registry, High Court Registry).
- Draft Your RTI Application: Clearly state the information you are seeking. Be specific about the type of documents (complaints, forwarding letters) and the time period.
- Submit the Application: Fill out the prescribed RTI application form and submit it to the Public Information Officer (PIO) of the concerned authority, along with the prescribed fee (usually ₹10).
- Follow Up: If you do not receive a response within 30 days (or 35 days if the PIO is not the head of the department), or if the response is unsatisfactory, you can file a First Appeal under Section 19 of the RTI Act.
Sample RTI question you can use:
Please provide copies of all forwarding letters, along with any accompanying complaints or related documents, sent Department of Justice to the Supreme Court and respective High Courts regarding complaints against Judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts, for the period from [Date – 1 year ago] to [Today’s Date]. Also, please provide any such documents that can be readily traced from the past three years, even if beyond the specified period.
Conclusion
This case demonstrates that even in sensitive areas, the RTI Act can be a powerful tool for citizens seeking accountability and transparency. While accessing information about complaints against judges might involve specific challenges, the CIC’s intervention ensures that public authorities cannot simply dismiss such requests due to poor record management. your rights and employing a strategic approach, you can effectively use RTI to seek information and uphold the principles of good governance in India.

