Navigating the complexities of filing an RTI application can sometimes feel like a maze, especially when it comes to understanding the correct way to pay the application fee. This case highlights a common point of confusion for many citizens: what happens when the prescribed mode of payment for an RTI application is rejected? Understanding this situation is crucial for ensuring your right to information is not obstructed hurdles. This article will break down a real-life RTI scenario and explain how the Central Information Commission (CIC) addressed the issue of fee payment, offering valuable lessons for all RTI applicants across India.
Background: What Information Was Sought
In this particular RTI case, the applicant was seeking information related to a public interest litigation (PIL) they had previously filed before the Bombay High Court. To obtain this information, they submitted an RTI application. However, the crucial point of contention arose with the payment of the application fee. The applicant had paid the fee using a postal order (IPO). The Public Information Officer (PIO) of the Bombay High Court refused to accept the application. The PIO cited the Bombay High Court RTI Rules, 2009, which were framed High Court itself under the powers vested in it as a competent authority as per Section 28 of the RTI Act. These rules, according to the PIO, stipulated that the application fee must be deposited only of cash, demand draft, or money order, explicitly excluding postal orders.
How the Public Authority Responded
The Public Information Officer (PIO) of the Bombay High Court did not accept the RTI application. The reason provided was that the fee had been paid via a postal order, which was not a permissible mode of payment according to the Bombay High Court RTI Rules, 2009. The applicant argued that since the Supreme Court of India accepts application fees through postal orders, the Bombay High Court should also follow suit. This argument highlighted the applicant’s belief in a uniform standard for fee payment across different high-level public authorities. However, the PIO adhered strictly to the specific rules laid down Bombay High Court.
The CIC Hearing: What Happened
The matter eventually reached the Central Information Commission (CIC) after the applicant appealed the PIO’s decision. During the hearing, the core issue revolved around whether the PIO was justified in rejecting the application solely based on the mode of fee payment. The applicant reiterated their argument about the Supreme Court’s practice. However, the CIC had to consider the legal framework governing the RTI Act. The Act empowers ‘competent authorities,’ such as High Courts, to frame their own rules for the discharge of their functions under the Act, including rules for the payment of fees. The CIC examined the Bombay High Court RTI Rules, 2009, and the PIO’s action in light of these rules. The Commission’s primary focus was on whether the applicant had complied with the prescribed procedure laid down specific public authority.
The CIC Order and Its Significance
The Central Information Commission (CIC), in its decision, upheld the PIO’s action. The Commission rejected the appeal, stating that the applicant could not compel the PIO to accept an RTI application that was not accompanied application fee in the manner prescribed relevant rules. The CIC emphasized that the Bombay High Court, as a competent authority, had the power to frame its own rules regarding the payment of fees, and adherence to these specific rules was mandatory for the acceptance of an RTI application. The Commission, however, offered a practical solution to the appellant. It advised the appellant to file a fresh RTI application, ensuring that the application fee was paid in the prescribed manner (cash, demand draft, or money order) if they were still interested in obtaining the information. This decision, while technically correct, underscored a potential practical difficulty for citizens.
Key Lessons for RTI Applicants
- Lesson 1: Understand Specific Rules for Fee Payment: It is crucial to remember that while the RTI Act provides a uniform right to information, specific public authorities, especially higher judicial bodies like High Courts, may have their own rules regarding the payment of application fees. Always check the website or official documentation of the public authority you are filing an RTI with to understand their specific fee payment procedures before submitting your application.
- Lesson 2: Adhere Strictly to Prescribed Modes of Payment: Do not assume that the mode of payment accepted public authority (like the Supreme Court) will be accepted . If the rules specify cash, demand draft, or money order, ensure you use one of these methods. Using an incorrect method can lead to your application being rejected, causing delays and frustration.
- Lesson 3: Be Prepared for Rejection and Re-filing: If your application is rejected due to a procedural error like incorrect fee payment, do not be discouraged. The CIC’s advice in this case shows that the path to information is often through re-application. Learn from the mistake, correct the procedure, and file a fresh application with the correct fee payment.
How to File a Similar RTI Application
- Identify the Correct Public Authority: Determine the specific department or office responsible for the information you seek.
- Check Fee Payment Rules: Visit the official website of the public authority or contact their RTI cell to ascertain the exact procedure and acceptable modes for paying the application fee.
- Prepare Your RTI Application: Clearly state the information you require. Ensure your request is specific and avoids ambiguity.
- Submit Application with Correct Fee: Pay the application fee using only the prescribed method (cash, demand draft, money order, etc., as per their rules). Attach proof of payment with your RTI application.
Sample RTI question you can use:
“As per the Bombay High Court RTI Rules, 2009, please provide a detailed list of all permissible modes of payment for the RTI application fee, along with the specific fee amount applicable for obtaining information related to public interest litigation filed before the High Court.”
Conclusion
This case serves as a potent reminder that while the RTI Act is a powerful tool for citizens, understanding and adhering to the specific procedural requirements of each public authority is paramount. The CIC’s decision, though technically sound, highlights the need for greater clarity and uniformity in fee payment procedures across all government bodies. As an RTI applicant, your diligence in checking and following these rules will significantly increase your chances of successfully obtaining the information you are entitled to. Remember, a well-prepared and correctly submitted RTI application is your first step towards transparency and accountability.
