Many Indian citizens use the Right to Information Act (RTI) to access information from government departments. However, sometimes RTI applications are transferred from one department to another. This raises a crucial question: If your RTI application is transferred, can you be asked to pay the application fee all over again? This case highlights a common dilemma faced applicants and provides clarity on this issue.
Background: What Information Was Sought
An RTI applicant had filed an application with the Ministry of Law and Justice. The Public Information Officer (PIO) of this ministry provided some information but decided to transfer one of the applicant’s queries to the PIO of the High Court of Gujarat. When the applicant approached the Gujarat High Court for the information, they were asked to deposit an application fee of Rs. 50/- before their request could be processed. The applicant felt this was unfair, as they had already paid the application fee to the Ministry of Law and Justice. They then filed a complaint with the Central Information Commission (CIC), arguing that the High Court should not demand a fresh fee.
How the Public Authority Responded
The PIO of the Gujarat High Court defended their request Rule 8(A)(ii) of the Gujarat High Court (Right to Information) Rules, 2005. This rule apparently prescribed an application fee of Rs. 50/- for providing any information. Therefore, they argued, the information could not be released without this prescribed fee. However, they did offer a compromise, suggesting the applicant deposit Rs. 40/- since Rs. 10/- had already been paid to the Ministry of Law and Justice.
The CIC Hearing: What Happened
The Central Information Commission (CIC) examined the case. The Commission noted that the RTI Act, 2005, does not explicitly state whether a public authority can levy a separate application fee when an RTI application is transferred under Section 6(4) of the Act, especially if an application fee has already been paid to the original authority. While acknowledging that the PIO of the Gujarat High Court was technically correct based on their specific rules, the Commission also considered the spirit of the RTI Act, which aims to facilitate access to information. The CIC observed that the administrative cost of correspondence and the potential appellate process would likely outweigh the Rs. 50/- fee demanded PIO. It would have been more in line with the RTI Act’s objectives if the PIO had considered providing the information without insisting on a fresh fee.
The CIC Order and Its Significance
The CIC directed the PIO of the Gujarat High Court to either provide the requested information to the appellant or, if they intended to deny it, to issue a “speaking order.” A speaking order is a detailed explanation of the reasons for denial. This decision is significant because it subtly encourages public authorities to be more pragmatic and less bureaucratic when dealing with transferred RTI applications, especially when a fee has already been paid. While not setting a blanket rule against charging fees on transferred applications, it emphasizes that the cost of administrative processes should be considered against the fee demanded, aligning with the goal of easy access to information.
Key Lessons for RTI Applicants
- Lesson 1: Understand Fee Rules Vary: Different states and even different public authorities might have their own specific rules regarding fees for information. It’s important to be aware of these, though the CIC’s approach suggests a pragmatic view.
- Lesson 2: Highlight Previous Payments: When your RTI application is transferred, clearly mention in your response to the new authority that you have already paid the application fee to the original department. Provide proof if possible.
- Lesson 3: Focus on the Spirit of RTI: If you believe a fee demand is unreasonable, especially after a transfer, you can raise this point in your complaint to the CIC, highlighting the administrative costs versus the fee and the spirit of Section 4 and other provisions of the RTI Act promoting transparency.
How to File a Similar RTI Application
- Identify the Correct Public Authority: Ensure you are filing your RTI application with the department that holds the information.
- Pay the Initial Application Fee: Pay the prescribed application fee of Rs. 10/- (or as per prevailing rules) with your initial RTI application.
- If Transferred, Respond Clearly: If your application is transferred, and the new authority asks for a fee, clearly state that you have already paid the application fee. Mention the amount and the department you paid it to.
- File a Complaint if Necessary: If you are unfairly asked to pay a fee again or your application is denied without proper justification, you can file a complaint with the Central Information Commission (CIC) or the relevant State Information Commission.
Sample RTI question you can use:
If an RTI application is transferred under Section 6(4) of the RTI Act, 2005, to another Public Authority after the application fee has already been paid to the original Public Authority, can the receiving Public Authority demand a fresh application fee for providing the information? If yes, under which specific rule or provision? Please provide details of any correspondence or internal guidelines on this matter.
Conclusion
This case demonstrates that while technical rules about fees exist, the spirit of the RTI Act often prevails in matters of access to information. It’s always best to be informed about your rights and responsibilities as an RTI applicant. how the system works and how to navigate potential hurdles, you can effectively use the RTI Act to hold public authorities accountable and ensure the free flow of information in India.

